ESG risk hasn’t disappeared because of the COVID-19
pandemic. Unfortunately, some firms have reverted to their Global Financial
Crisis playbook and accidentally opened up a swathe of avenues for criticism.
Environmental, social, and governance risks are particularly acute in a crisis.
Many firms have done a fantastic job of looking after their stakeholders
during this crisis. Unfortunately, others have not been behaving as the good
corporate citizens that exist in their marketing and their annual report
The rise of ESG issues over the past decade was reaching its
crescendo at the World Economic Forum in Davos just two months ago. There is no
reason why firms who care about these issues will revert to old habits if they
have embraced managing these risks inside their business in line with community
If anything, this current crisis will heighten the level of
scrutiny on everything a company does. Every press release, every employment
decision, every change to a product or service – they will all be under the
The level of panic and fear in the community around COVID-19
and its health and economic fallout means that boards and senior executives
need to think carefully about how their actions will be perceived and
interpreted by the community.
Environment risks include climate change, the natural
environment, pollution, waste, and environmental opportunities for firms to create
a positive impact on environmental outcomes.
Because of the COVID-19 pandemic, and the rise of working
from home, there is a massive opportunity for firms to reconsider their office
space footprint. If remote working is the new normal, customers can still
Firms can use a different mix of activities that rely less on
office space, such as video calling. A lower office space footprint will reduce
the firm’s overall environmental footprint as long as business travel remains cancelled
or not possible.
New ways of working across a firm’s end-to-end value chain
will need to consider what other firms in your value chain are doing at the
same time to reduce their environmental footprint.
Social risks include the wellbeing and development of
workers, health & safety, supply chain issues, product design, controversies
and positive social impact initiatives.
The natural response of many firms has been to immediately furlough
workers to reduce costs. If revenue has gone to zero, then cutting costs is obvious.
However, some firms have made responsible decisions – paid sick leave for staff
needing to self-isolate due to COVID-19, paying wages where they can for the
duration of a lockdown, and continuing to pay health insurance premiums.
Some firms are even partnering with organisations in other
industries needing lots of staff quickly to offer opportunities to their furloughed
workers. Health and safety actions are even more critical during this time. The
provision of PPE is essential – if it can’t occur, then boards and senior executives
should think very carefully about whether it is responsible to open at all
without providing this to staff.
The way that some firms have chosen to treat staff is
already causing controversy. On the other side of the bridge, they will face
unfair dismissal claims and litigation from suppliers treated poorly. Other
firms have endeavoured to pay their invoices faster and settle trade creditors
and contractors where possible before closing their operations temporarily.
Governance risks include corporate governance issues such as
board composition, executive remuneration, shareholding composition and accounting
standards used in financial reporting. Organisational behaviour issues such as tax
policy, ethics, anti-competitive actions and financial stability are risks
Sharing the pain is a smart decision many boards and senior
executives have already taken. Pay cuts and no bonuses are the bare minimum act
of corporate social responsibility if you are standing down thousands of employees.
Firm-wide pay cuts to protect jobs instead of redundancies
can also work here. How many boards have turned over completely since the GFC?
For most, this will be their first major crisis and letting senior managers
deal with the crisis and focusing on governance as opposed to micro-managing
will be a challenge for some.
Board composition needs to be a blend of different experience
and perspectives – how many will have thought through the productivity
implications for their workforce if school kids are at home during this crisis?
Managers being genuine about workplace flexibility where possible will be a differentiator
on the other side of the bridge.
Executive remuneration in the coming years will be even more
sensitive than after the Global Financial Crisis. You see, many people never
thought anything changed after the GFC. If Australia is facing its highest
levels of unemployment since the Great Depression, even the at-risk potential
numbers when it comes to executive remuneration could be a target for regulators.
Considerations For Boards And Senior Executives
Boards and senior executives will be under a lot of pressure
right now. Many have invoked their business continuity plan or had to manage
crises non-stop since this pandemic escalated in severity worldwide. A key
consideration at the back of your mind is how stakeholders will perceive the
firm’s actions during this crisis.
Are you doing the right thing by your employees? Are you
doing the right thing by your customers? Are you doing the right thing by your
suppliers and key partners? Are you doing the right thing by your community? In
the age of social media, there will be real-time feedback on the appropriateness
of your actions. In the age of continuous disclosure, your share price will be
gyrating each day based on traders assessment of whether you have this
situation under reasonable control where you can.
A lot of fluff is written about values and corporate social
responsibility. A crisis is where firms that live what they believe and stay
true to their word get to demonstrate to the world their integrity. Customers,
employees, shareholders, stakeholders and the community at large will recognise
that and reward it on the other side of the bridge.